Charmander - Wizards of the Coast Black Star Promo #9 (Non-Holo)

Estimated value
$5 - $30Rarity
Average(4/10)Category
Trading CardsBrand
Wizards of the Coast / PokémonEra
Late 1990s - Early 2000sOrigin
🇺🇸 United StatesArtist / Creator
Mitsuhiro AritaAuthenticity
COLLECTOR'S BREAKDOWN: CHARMANDER - WIZARDS OF THE COAST BLACK STAR PROMO #9 (NON-HOLO)
This is a non-Holo 'Charmander' card, card number 9 from the Wizards of the Coast Black Star Promotional Set. It's a Basic Pokémon, Level 10, with 60 HP. The artwork depicts Charmander, a fire-type lizard Pokémon, standing in a grassy landscape with its iconic flaming tail. The card features the 'Scratch' and 'Ember' attacks, common for early-stage Pokémon. The artist credit appears to be 'Mitsuhiro Arita'.
CULTURAL CARD LORE
Where This Object Echoes
Charmander, as a fire-lizard, draws upon mythical serpentine or draconic creatures associated with fire and potent energy in various East Asian mythologies.
The design of Charmander embodies archetypal 'starter' companions in fantasy narratives, providing an accessible entry point to a larger magical world.
Ritual & Ceremonial Use
- •The ritualistic collection and trading of these cards among children and adults, fostering social interaction and a sense of community.
- •The act of 'battling' with these cards, simulating a creature fight with specific rules and strategies, mirroring the video game experience.
Meaning Through Time
During its initial release, this Charmander card, as a promo, represented an exclusive bonus item, a tangible connection to the burgeoning Pokémon phenomenon for fans.
Today, this card serves as a nostalgic artifact for many, representing a childhood memory, and for collectors, an entry-level piece of a comprehensive set of Black Star Promos.
CARD HISTORY & PRINT RUNS
COLLECTOR INTEL
Mitsuhiro Arita, the artist for this Charmander card, is one of the most prolific and beloved Pokémon TCG artists, known for illustrating iconic cards like the original Base Set Charizard.
Charmander is one of the three starter Pokémon from the original Pokémon Red and Blue video games, representing the fire-type option, and eventually evolves into the powerful Charizard.
HOW SCARCE IS IT?
Typical antique shop fare. Requires some searching but regularly available. This is where most genuine antiques fall.
Typical Characteristics
- Standard antique shop items
- Regularly available
- Moderate collector interest
Confidence Factors
- Well-documented and common promotional card.
- No apparent errors in text, font, or art that would indicate a counterfeit.
- Non-holographic cards are less commonly counterfeited due to lower value.
GRADING EXPERT'S TAKE
Trading Card Market Analyst
Confidence is high due to the clear identification of the Pokémon, set, and card number. The visible details align perfectly with known authentic copies of this specific promotional card.
KEY EVIDENCE
- 1The card clearly shows 'Charmander' as a Basic, LV.10, 60 HP Pokémon.
- 2The 'Wizards of the Coast' copyright and card number '9' (visible in the lower right corner) identify it as a Black Star Promo card.
- 3The artist credit 'Mitsuhiro Arita' is present, typical for authentic WotC era cards.
- 4No holographic pattern is visible on the artwork, confirming it as the non-holo version.
UNCERTAINTIES
- •Image clarity is moderate; closer, direct overhead shots would allow for a more precise condition assessment of edges and surface.
WHAT WOULD IMPROVE CERTAINTY
- →High-resolution scan of the front and back for detailed analysis of corners, edges, and surface imperfections.
- →Examination of the card under angled light to detect any subtle indentations or scratches not visible in current images.
- →Obtain a clear image of the card's back to assess back centering and any whitening on the edges.
- →A direct comparison against a known authentic copy for printing details and card stock consistency.
CONDITION & GRADE
Condition
The card shows some noticeable wear, particularly on the edges and corners, suggesting it's been handled and played. The centering appears decent but could be improved. Some minor surface scratching is visible which would impact grading.
Surface
The card appears to have a matte paper finish with bright colors for the artwork. There's no visible holographic pattern, indicating a non-holo common version of this promotional card. The surface seems relatively smooth but showing some minor scuffing.
Weight & feel
Lightweight, typical for a standard trading card, approximately 1-2 grams. It would feel slightly thinner than a modern card due to older card stock.
TRADING CARD MARKET VALUE
Updated: Feb 27, 2026
- Market comparables from auctions & retail
- Condition, completeness & craftsmanship
- Current collector demand & trends
- Low = quick sale, high = patient seller
For informational purposes only, not a formal appraisal.
SIMILAR CURIOSITIES
Gardevoir ex (Special Illustration Rare) - Scarlet & Violet: Temporal Forces [086/198]
Mew ex Special Art Rare - Pokémon Card (Japanese)
Tropical Tidal Wave (Cavallone Tropicale) - World Championship Promo [036]
Magikarp - Pokémon Card 151 (Special Art Rare) [080/165]
Super Saiyan Vegeta (2024 DBS FSN World JP) - FB01-096 - PSA 10 GEM MINT
Mega Gengar ex - Cyber Judge (Special Illustration Rare) [SV5M 093/071]
MORE BY MITSUHIRO ARITA
Charizard - 20th Anniversary CP6 (Holo) [011/087 R]
Gardevoir EX (Full Art) - XY BREAKpoint [116/114]
Koffing LV.13 60 HP - Evolutions (Common/Reverse Holo) [68/108]
Dewgong - Aquapolis (Common) [29/103]
Zubat - Team Rocket (1st Edition) [70/82]
Electrike (Basic) - EX Trainer Kit 2 (64/110)
ABOUT TRADING CARDS
Pokemon cards, sports cards, gaming cards, TCGs, and collectible card games.
Trading Cards value and rarity guideSHARE THIS CURIOSITY
Have your own curiosities to discover?
Scan Your Curiosity
COMMENTS
No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts!
Sign in to leave a comment