Skip to main content

Catholic Donor Recognition Broadside - Early 20th Century Lithograph

Estimated value

$150 - $450

Rarity

Scarce(6/10)

Era

circa 1890-1920

Origin

United States

Visual assessment

Photo analysis

Save to revisit in your watchlist. This does not add the object to your own collection.

55

Catholic Donor Recognition Broadside - Early 20th

A formal donor recognition document, likely a lithographic print on paper, featuring a central illustration of the Virgin Mary (Assumption or Immaculate Conception) in a Gothic-arched lunette. The layout is organized into three primary columns titled 'DONOR' listing numerous individuals and Catholic organizations, such as the Good Shepherd Convent and the Charity Club. The typography utilizes a mix of blackletter Gothic and serif fonts, characteristic of ecclesiastical printing from the late 19th to early 20th century.

The piece is framed and appears to be a commemorative record of contributions for a specific parish, school, or charitable foundation.

A robed figure appears within a pointed arch above the central list.
A robed figure appears within a pointed arch above the central list.

Related traditions

Roman Catholic

Medieval to Modern

The 'Liber Vitae' or Book of Life tradition of recording benefactors' names for perpetual prayer.

Use and ceremony

Parochial fundraising and dedication ceremonies for new church altars or windows.

  1. 1900

    A public testament of faith and community standing through financial charity.

  2. Modern

    A genealogical resource and historical artifact of regional immigration patterns.

Origins and context

Catholic donor boards and broadsides were common in North American urban parishes between 1890 and 1930 as a means of documenting large-scale fundraising for new church construction or convent hospitalities. The presence of names like 'Chouteau' and 'Goessling' suggests a possible connection to the St. Louis, Missouri region, where these families were prominent in Catholic philanthropy. These documents served as both a spiritual 'book of life' and a social record of the parish hierarchy.

Further details

1

The names Goessling and Chouteau on this list link it to the historic 'First Families' of St. Louis, dating back to the city's founding in 1764.

2

Similar commemorative lithographs were often mass-produced by firms like Benziger Brothers, who specialized in Catholic 'church goods' between 1853 and 1960.

Attribution and evidence

The upper right donor list includes the words “Shepherd Convent.”
The upper right donor list includes the words “Shepherd Convent.”

The identification of the object type is certain based on visual layout, though exact parish location is inferred from the notable surnames visible.

Identifying details

  • 1Specific surname patterns (Chouteau, Delaney, Goessling) suggest a Midwestern US Catholic context.
  • 2Gothic revival aesthetics in the central lunette and borders.
  • 3Presence of religious orders like 'Good Shepherd Convent' as institutional donors.
  • 4Standardized lithographic printing techniques visible in the border ornamentation.

Open questions

  • •Significant moisture damage along the lower decorative border may indicate potential mold or rot within the frame.
  • •Low image resolution obscures specific parish signatures or location stamps.
Photographs that would help
  • Examine the verso (back) of the frame for any handwritten notes or specialized framer's labels from St. Louis or Chicago.
  • Check for a small printer's mark (slug) in the bottom margin, such as 'Benziger Bros' or 'H.M. Litho Co.'
  • Inspect under UV light to determine the extent of the damp-staining and check for previous restorative attempts.
Terms in this record
Foxing
Age-related spots and browning on paper caused by fungal growth or the oxidation of iron or copper particles.
Lunette
An arched aperture or decorated area, here containing the central figure of Mary.
Broadside
A large sheet of paper printed on one side only, intended to be posted or framed.

Wear and preservation

Fair to Good
The lower portion shows uneven brown discoloration around the printed text.
The lower portion shows uneven brown discoloration around the printed text.

Structural integrity is maintained, but aesthetic value is compromised by visible water damage at the bottom and overall paper toning.

Significant damp-staining and 'foxing' (brown spots from iron oxidation in paper) are evident, particularly affecting the lower marginalia and central columns. The framing appears to be mid-20th century, which may not be acid-free, contributing to the paper's discoloration.

Paper and printing

Lithographic ink on likely heavy-stock cream paper; some foxing and localized staining visible in the lower quadrant.

Recorded physical details

The object is framed and glazed, suggesting it is relatively heavy and fragile for its 18x24 inch approximate size.

Scarcity and surviving examples

Scarce · 6/10 estimated rarity

This is a qualitative collection score, not a measured survival count, market percentile or proof of authenticity.

What the photographs establish

Interpretation of the photographs and supplied context. This does not authenticate the object.

  • Typography and layout are perfectly consistent with Catholic institutional printing of the 1900s.
  • Visible aging (foxing and staining) shows natural progression for non-archival paper stored in a frame.
What photo analysis can and cannot establish

Value and its basis

$150 - $450

Estimate recorded: May 11, 2026

How we estimate value

Estimate context (not a documented sale): Similar regional donor broadsides have appeared on auction sites like eBay and at local Missouri antique malls for approximately $200-$350 depending on frame quality.

Collectors and interest

Genealogists researching the specific families listed or collectors of Catholic parochial history and regional ephemera.

What supports the estimate

  • •Identification of the specific church or cathedral it originated from
  • •Presence of historically significant regional surnames (e.g., Chouteau)
  • •Aesthetic appeal of the Gothic lithography

What could change it

  • •Extensive moisture damage at the bottom margin
  • •Lack of a specific church name in the current visible area

Comparing quality

  • •Pristine condition with no foxing or water stains
  • •Original 19th-century carved ecclesiastical frame
  • •Direct link to a well-known historic cathedral

The effect of condition

Paper acidity, foxing intensity, moisture damage, and clarity of the printed names.

Market interest

ScarceNiche demandSpecialist market
Browse similar relics objects

For informational purposes only, not a formal appraisal.

rayklinkergmailcom’s cabinet

RA

rayklinkergmailcom

Wonderseeker•1 item

Join the conversation

Explore Historical Relics

Artifacts from pivotal moments, battlefield remnants, historical documents, and pieces of major events.

Historical Relics value and rarity guide

A place for your relics

Keep its photographs, maker’s marks and the story you know in one object record. Start with a photo.

Add an object

Create an account for 10 free scans. No credit card needed.